Prophet Mohammed pbuh ordered murder of a jewish poetess woman Asma Binte Marvan? Lie or Truth
ACCUSATION By Zulfiqar Tareen [An Atheist]
The jewish poetess, Asma binte marwan, wrote a poem to denounce the murder of poet Abu afaq at the hands of muhammad’s assassins. muhammad in response asked his followers,” who would get me rid of this daughter of marwan”. Omair ibn aadi swore to take care of her. He waited for the night and entered her tent in the darkness. He plunged the knife in asma’s
According to Ibn ishaq islam became powerful that day and all the members of Asma’s family accepted islam ( sirat rasul allah, page # 675, by ibn ishaq, written in medina 1300 years ago ).
“Did’t the jews insult the JESUS Christ??”
“Does’t the americans insults chineese and fabricate stories??”
“Does’t the Iranian PRESS TV produce news which americans denies?”
“Does’t the CNN filters out anti-american news especially their utter destruction by the hands of mujahideen in Iraq and Afghanistan”????
There is a subject taught in the Hadith Studies called “ISMA UL RIJJAL” that testifies and authenticate each and every hadith based on the chain of people through which it was received. They also check if the narrators are considered trustful among their peers and mates or they are considered liars among their people themselves.
THE 2 BILLION MUSLIMS AND GROWING
ARE A CLEAR EVIDENCE THAT
THEIR COMBINE INTELLIGENCE IS FAR STRONGER THEN
Selective Picking of Zulfiqar Tareen sahib, who copy pastes but never responds when refuted : )
Ibn Ishaq’s Sīratu Rasūlu l-Lāh, an important early work of sīra, was composed over 100 years after the Prophet’s death using oral traditions passed down from his early followers. However, its accuracy for use as hadith, a body of traditions of the prophet that Muslim scholars use to flesh out Islamic doctrine, is not completely accepted. This particular story has been challenged by Muslim scholars for having a weak chain of transmission (that is, they deem it difficult to determine if the oral traditions can be traced precisely back to a witness of the events described during Muhammad’s life).
Ibn Ishaq’s version of the story has a number of chains of transmission (isnads) that go back to Ibn ‘Abbas, a companion of Muhammad. However, all those various isnads include Muhammad ibn al-Hajjaj al-Lakhmi:
Muhammad ibn Ibrahim al-Shami → Muhammad ibn al-Hajjaj al-Lakhmi → Mujalid ibn Sa’ed → Al-Shu’abi → Ibn ‘Abbas
Muhammad ibn al-Hajjaj al-Lakhmi has been accused by hadith scholars of fabricating this and other hadiths. Ibn ʻAdī (died 976) stated: “…this isnad (chain of reporters) is not narrated on authority of Mujalid but by Muhammad ibn al-Hajjaj al-Lakhmi and they all (other reporters in the chain) accuse Muhammad Ibn Al-Hajjaj of forging it”. Ibn al-Jawzi (died 1201) said something similar in his Al-‘ilal.
Regarding Al-Lakhmi, Al-Bukhari said: “his hadith is abandoned”, Yahya ibn Ma’een said: “compulsive liar” and once said: “not trustworthy”. Al-Daraqutni denounced him as a liar.
STORY FABRICATION AND AGAINST THE TEACHINGS OF ISLAM
In the authentic Sunnah of the Prophet (Sallallahu Alaihi Wa sallam) prohibits the killing of women in war. (note: in Islam a women can only be put to death if she commited murder as crime)
Narrated Ibn ‘Umar: Messenger of Allah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) saw the corpse of a woman who had been slain in one of the raids, and he disapproved of it and forbade the killing of women and children. (Bukhari, Vol. 4, Bk. 52, No. 257 & 258).
Due to this prohibition, scholars of Abu Hanifah’s Madhab (school of thought) have stated that apostate women are not to be killed because the Prophet (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) forbade the killing of women, and since the prohibition is general it includes apostate women. (Sharh Ad-Durr-el-Mukhtar, Volume 1, p. 483, ‘Ainul Hidayah commentary of Al Hidayah Vol. 2 Pg. 585)
IF THE PROPHET ACTED AGAINST HIS OWN TEACHINGS,
THEN HE COULD NOT HAVE RECEIVED SUCH
APPRECIATION FROM HIS OWN COMPANIONS
Even after the Prophet’s demise, his Sunnah remain preserved by the Muslims:
Abu Bakr advised Yazid: “I advise you ten things: Do not kill women or children or an aged, infirm person. Do not cut down fruit-bearing trees. Do not destroy an inhabited place. Do not slaughter sheep or camel except for food. Do not burn bees and do not scatter them. Do not steal from the booty, and do not be cowardly.” (Mutta Malik, Book 21, Section 3, Number 10)
Therefore, based on the evidences, we can therefore conclude that the killing of Asma’ bint Marwan are false.
STORY DID NOT COME FOR JEWS
The story did’t come from the JEWS side..
but from the Muslims Side : )
Had the muslims felt it such a “strong evidence” against Mohammed, they would have emitted it form their books forever, not to be received by Zulfiqar sahib : ) for cut pasting.
Rather they knew it was false and fabricated and retained it as examples of fabrication to be studied under the subject of “Isma ul Rijjal”.
THE UNJUST PEOPLE ARE THOSE WHO WANT TO GET BENEFIT FROM THIS WORLD
What position did prophet mohammed pbuh took for himself having acquired the kingdom of Arab and having 100,000 followers on the day of last sermon???
His companions always saw him offering prayers in day and night, crying for the forgiveness of the mankind, worship God more the any of his follower, always quoting from Quran the very book he preached, and he made QURAN a law binding upon himself ! eating less then one meal a day, wearing the most cheapest of the dresses, and living in most ordinary of the houses available ! When ever he received any gift from his friends he always distributed among the poor!
He died in the arms of his beloved wife Aisha !
A Man who always remembered and loved his first wife Khudaija, the noble woman more then of her age and who herself send him the proposal having seeing his honesty and trustworthiness in maintaining her business. !
A MAN IS FOLLOWED WHEN PEOPLE AROUND HIM CONSIDER HIM HONEST AND TRUSTWORTHY
his 100,000 followers were seen laying their lives for his cause.
YOU CAN NOT MAKE A SINGLE FREE MAN spend all his life (even your husband) to do what you want him to do !
but prophet mohammed has such a charismatic influence, then still 2 BILLION PEOPLE ON THE GLOBE AND GROWING wish to do any thing they can for the love of their Prophet..